The Unbelievable Truth

The Unbelievable Truth

Can a nice girl from Long Island find happiness with a mass murderer?

R 1990 · 90 min · ★ 6.9 · Comedy , Drama , Romance

After serving time for murder, Josh Hutton returns to his home town where he meets Audry Hugo. No one can remember exactly what Josh did...

Directed by Hal Hartley · Written by Hal Hartley

Your Rating

Where to Watch

Rent or Buy

Amazon Video
Provider data from JustWatch via TMDB →

Cast

More from Hal HartleySee all →

FlirtFlirt · 1993
Flirt
9.01993
MovieComedyRomance
In New York, Bill struggles to decide whether he has a future with Emily, while attempting to restrain Walter, the angry husband of a woman he thinks he might be in love with. Later incorporated into a feature film of the same name.
Red OaksRed Oaks · 2014
Red Oaks
7.42014
SeriesComedyDrama
A coming-of-age comedy set in the "go-go" 80s that is equal parts hijinks and heartfelt about a college student enjoying a last hurrah before summer comes to an end--and the future begins. David Myers, an assistant tennis pro at the Red Oaks Country Club in suburban New Jersey in 1985, is both reeling from his father's heart attack and conflicted about what major to declare in the fall. While there, he meets a colorful cast of misfit co-workers and wealthy club members including an alluring art student named Skye and her corporate raider father Getty.
Surviving DesireSurviving Desire · 1992
Surviving Desire
6.91992
MovieComedyDrama
Jude, a college professor, is obsessed with Sophie, his student. She, in turn, is intrigued by his scholarly charm. Flirtation turns to lust and the two become lovers.
TrustTrust · 1990
Trust
6.81990
MovieDramaComedy
After being thrown away from home, pregnant high school dropout Maria meets Matthew, a highly educated and extremely moody electronics repairman. The two begin an unusual romance built on their sense of mutual admiration and trust.
Simple MenSimple Men · 1992
Simple Men
6.71992
MovieCrimeDrama
Two diametrically opposite brothers set off on a journey to reunite with their estranged father but when their motorcycle breaks down while passing through a small town, they become entangled in local life.
DogsDogs · 1988
Dogs
6.71988
MovieDrama
A short film about friendship, disillusionment, loathing and despair, in which the pictures of three young men talking are juxtaposed with slowmotion shots of aggressive dogs. Three young men are talking about Richie's marriage to Evelyn, which has put their friendship on the back burner. Richie explains how that could happen. "She fell for me, and they hate me for it", he says. Everyone was mad about Evelyn, but Richie makes it clear that their marriage is not exactly a bed of roses. He admits that be bluffed and lied and more or less asks his friends for forgiveness.
AdrienneAdrienne · 2021
Adrienne
6.62021
MovieDocumentaryDrama
As the muse of Hal Hartley’s indie classics and as writer/director of the critically acclaimed Waitress, Adrienne Shelly was a shining star in the indie film firmament. A devoted young mother, her life was right on track until her husband found her dead. Filmmaker Andy Ostroy has been fighting to discover the truth about his wife’s death ever since.
American PlayhouseAmerican Playhouse · 1982
American Playhouse
6.61982
SeriesDramaComedy
American Playhouse is an anthology television series periodically broadcast by Public Broadcasting Service in the United States.
Henry FoolHenry Fool · 1998
Henry Fool
6.61998
MovieComedyDrama
An egocentric bum transforms the lives of a shy New Jersey garbageman and his sister.
NYC 3/94NYC 3/94 · 1994
NYC 3/94
6.51994
Movie
The mundane circumstances of a city under siege.
The Book of LifeThe Book of Life · 1998
The Book of Life
6.41998
MovieComedyFantasy
New Year's Eve takes on new meaning when the Devil, Jesus Christ, and Christ's assistant Magdalena discuss and debate the End of the World.
FlirtFlirt · 1995
Flirt
6.21995
MovieDramaRomance
The same situation is played out in different cities (New York, Berlin and Tokyo). A lover has to choose whether to commit to a partner who is returning home. In each case there are other people involved, an ex-partner and someone else in a "permanent" relationship, what do they choose to do?
AmateurAmateur · 1994
Amateur
6.11994
MovieCrimeComedy
A man wakes up in an alley, bleeding and with no memory of who he is. He stumbles into a coffee shop and is befriended by a charitable ex-nun who is failing in her attempts to write marketable pornography.
No Such ThingNo Such Thing · 2002
No Such Thing
6.02002
MovieFantasyDrama
A young journalist journeys to Iceland to find her missing fiancé only to encounter a mythical creature who longs to die.
AdventureAdventure · 2010
Adventure
6.02010
MovieDocumentary
Hartley and his wife, Miho Nikaido, travel to Japan to see her parents and reflect on 12 years of marriage, her career ambitions, and the adventures of growing older.
Ned RifleNed Rifle · 2015
Ned Rifle
5.82015
MovieDrama
Henry’s and Fay's son Ned sets out to find and kill his father for destroying his mother's life. But his aims are frustrated by the troublesome Susan, whose connection to Henry predates even his arrival in the lives of the Grim family.

More Like This

TrustTrust · 1990
Trust
6.81990
MovieDramaComedy
After being thrown away from home, pregnant high school dropout Maria meets Matthew, a highly educated and extremely moody electronics repairman. The two begin an unusual romance built on their sense of mutual admiration and trust.
Lock UpLock Up · 1989
Lock Up
6.81989
MovieActionCrime
Frank Leone is nearing the end of his prison term for a relatively minor crime. Just before he is paroled, however, Warden Drumgoole takes charge. Drumgoole was assigned to a hell-hole prison after his administration was publicly humiliated by Leone, and has now arrived on the scene to ensure that Leone never sees the light of day.
Tough GuysTough Guys · 1986
Tough Guys
6.01986
MovieComedyCrime
Harry Doyle and Archie Lang are two old-time train robbers, who held up a train in 1956 and have been incarcerated for thirty years. After serving their time, they are released from jail and have to adjust to a new life of freedom. and soon realize that they still have the pizzazz when, picking up their prison checks at a bank, they foil a robbery attempt.
The Great GatsbyThe Great Gatsby · 1974
The Great Gatsby
6.31974
MovieDramaRomance
Nick Carraway, a young Midwesterner now living on Long Island, finds himself fascinated by the mysterious past and lavish lifestyle of his neighbor, the nouveau riche Jay Gatsby. He is drawn into Gatsby's circle, becoming a witness to obsession and tragedy.
Buffalo '66Buffalo '66 · 1998
Buffalo '66
7.11998
MovieDramaRomance
Billy is released after five years in prison. In the next moment, he kidnaps teenage student Layla and visits his parents with her, pretending she is his girlfriend and they will soon marry.
Hallelujah!Hallelujah! · 2009
Hallelujah!
5.82009
MovieComedy
Following his release from a seven-year stretch in prison, Mario Diccara discovers that his affairs with the underworld aren't completely settled. His brother Patrick, a priest, suggests that he stays with elderly Father Etienne in a small village in Ardeche until the conflict blows over. But their plan takes an unexpected turn when Father Etienne dies.
L.I.E.L.I.E. · 2001
L.I.E.
6.72001
MovieDramaCrime
With his mother dead and his father busy at work, Howie feels adrift in his New York suburb. He and his friend Gary spend their time burglarizing their neighbors' homes — until they make the mistake of robbing the house of Big John, a macho former Marine who is also an unrepentant pedophile. He propositions Howie, who declines, but the two eventually develop an unlikely and dangerous friendship.
Betsy's WeddingBetsy's Wedding · 1990
Betsy's Wedding
5.71990
MovieComedyRomance
Offbeat fashion student Betsy Hopper and her straight-laced investment-banker fiancé Jake Lovell just want an intimate little wedding reception, but Betsy's father Eddie, a Long Island construction contractor, feels so threatened by Jake's rich WASP parents that he blows the ceremony up into a bank-breaking showpiece, sending his wife Lola into a financial panic.
The YardsThe Yards · 2000
The Yards
6.22000
MovieCrimeDrama
In the rail yards of Queens, contractors repair and rebuild the city's subway cars. These contracts are lucrative, so graft and corruption are rife. When Leo Handler gets out of prison, he finds his aunt married to Frank Olchin, one of the big contractors; he's battling with a minority-owned firm for contracts.
DolemiteDolemite · 1975
Dolemite
5.81975
MovieActionComedy
Dolemite is a pimp who was set up by Willie Greene and the cops, who have planted drugs, stolen furs, and guns in his trunk and got him sentenced to 20 years in jail. One day, Queen B and a warden planned to get him out of Jail and get Willie Green and Mitchell busted for what they did to him.
GatorGator · 1976
Gator
5.21976
MovieDramaCrime
After his release from prison, notorious ex-con and moonshine distiller Gator McKlusky moves in with his father in a cabin in the Okefenokee Swamp. His bootlegging plans are cut short, however, when a federal agent tells McKlusky that he will lose custody of his 9-year-old daughter unless he helps bring down local crime lord Bama McCall. McKlusky enlists the help of reporter Aggie Maybank and a few local eccentrics to bring down McCall's empire.
TendernessTenderness · 2009
Tenderness
5.22009
MovieCrimeDrama
A hardened cop tries to unravel the past to discover whether a violent teenager was responsible for the murder of his family. A confused fifteen-year-old runaway becomes enthralled with the young man.
The WomenThe Women · 1939
The Women
7.21939
MovieComedyDrama
A happily married woman lets her catty friends talk her into divorce when her husband strays.
SupremacySupremacy · 2014
Supremacy
5.72014
MovieCrimeDrama
The story centers on paroled white supremacist who has just killed a cop, and takes a black family hostage. Within hours of being released from 14 years of solitary confinement in maximum-security Pelican Bay State Prison, Garrett Tully is on the run again. When he finds a house off a dirt road and takes a family hostage, he thinks the Aryan Brotherhood has his back–and his kidnap victims are black. The family’s patriarch, Mr. Walker, is a jaded ex-con who hates cops so much he disavowed his own son for becoming one. Seeing a familiar desperation in Tully, Walker refuses to call the authorities for help, causing familial tensions to escalate, and soon grave missteps are made.
Trapped in ParadiseTrapped in Paradise · 1994
Trapped in Paradise
5.71994
MovieComedyCrime
Residents of a friendly Pennsylvania town foil three brothers' plan to rob a bank on Christmas Eve.

Rate this film

Your ratings make Midnight smarter